Oduvjek. Očito ne razumiješ što znači star trek kanon, ni što je kršenje kanona.

Kakve to ima veze što brod izgleda drugačije. Najvjerojatnije su ga renovirali kad je Kirk postao kapetan.

Ista situacija je i u prvom star trek filmu. U njemu Enterprise NCC-1701 izgleda potpuno drugačije nego što je izgledao u seriji. Zašto? Zato što je renoviran.

A i likovi u prvom filmu izgledaju puno drugačije nego u seriji. Ja sam tek nakon polovice filma prepoznao Scottyja.

EDIT: A otkud ti toliko precizno znaš kad se odvija radnja tog filma.

ALTERNATIVNI VREMENSKI FU**ING PRAVAC!!!
Daj shvati više, novi film je reboot. Bye Bye TOS...

Ne, ne krši. Zaobilazi ga.
U originalnom vremenskom pravcu sve je po starom, a kanon je neokrznut.

Nije. Nedavno je Roberto Orci (scenarist filma) detaljno pričao o tome u interviewu za TrekMovie.com

evo ti, pa vidi svojim očima:

Anthony: So what happens with the destruction of the Kelvin is the creation of an alternative timeline, but what happens to the prime timeline after Nero leaves it? Does it continue or does it wink out of existence once he goes back and creates this new timeline.

Bob: It continues. According to the most successful, most tested scientific theory ever, quantum mechanics, it continues.

Anthony: So everyone in the prime timeline, like Picard and Riker, are still off doing there thing, it is just that Nero is gone.

Bob: Yes, and you will notice that whenever the movie comes out, that whatever DVDs you have purchased, will continue to exist.

Bob: If you look at quantum mechanics and you learn about the fact that our most successful theory of science is quantum mechanics, and the fact that it deals with probabilities of events happening. And that the most probable events tend to happen more often and that one of the subsets of that theory is the many universe theory. Data said this [in "Parallels"], he summed up quantum mechanics as the theory that "all possibilities that can happen do happen" in a parallel universe. According to theory, there are going to be a much larger number of universes in which events are very closely related, because those are the most probable configurations of things. Inherent in quantum mechanics there is sort of reverse entropy, which is what you were trying to say, in which the universe does tend to want to order itself in a certain way. This is not something we are making up; this is something we researched, in terms of the physical theory. So yes, there is an element of the universe trying to hold itself together.

Znaš kako tvoja omiljena kapetanica kaže: "Temporal paradoxes give me a headache" i "There's no time like the present"

Nije važno što kaže. Ta njihova teorija se kosi sa kanonom. A i sa ostalim teorijama koje danas postoje.

Odnosno nova materija ne može nastati iz ničega. A stvaranje novog svemira bi značilo stvaranje nove materije.

Okej, da ti ja sad tu postam sliku banane, ti bi rekla "to nije banana, to je krastavac, i taj krastavac krši kanon, dakle banana nije kanon"


Bubne Rai'tara, i ostade živa...
Odustajem...

Nisam ništa bubnula, to ti je fizika. Nova materija ne može nastati iz ničega.

Kvantna fizika je ipak nešto malo egzotičnije...
Odustajem, pokušaj #2

BTW, Bob Orci obrazlaže svoj stav navodeći nešto što je Data rekao u epki "Paralells."
Hoćeš reći da ni ta epka nije kanon? Možda po tebi ni Data nije kanon?

Očito je Data falio kad je to rekao jer se kosi sa jako puno događaja viđenim u star treku.